As the 2026 NFL Draft approaches, mock drafts are buzzing with the Tennessee Titans selecting All-American running back Jeremiyah Love with the coveted fourth overall pick. While Love is a phenomenal talent—arguably the top prospect in the entire class—this move would be a strategic misstep for the franchise, highlighting a crucial lesson in team building: elite talent needs the right environment to thrive.
Recent history provides a perfect case study. Look at the divergent paths of Jahmyr Gibbs and Ashton Jeanty. Gibbs landed in an ideal situation with the Detroit Lions, playing behind a top-tier offensive line, alongside a complementary back in David Montgomery, and within a creative offense orchestrated by Ben Johnson. The result? A superstar who leads his draft class in career value and has already racked up nearly 5,000 scrimmage yards.
Contrast that with Ashton Jeanty's rookie year in Las Vegas. Despite his high draft pedigree, Jeanty was hamstrung by a struggling offensive line, questionable coaching, and a lack of supporting weapons. The result was a high volume of touches that translated into inefficient production, a stark reminder that even the most gifted runner can be neutralized by a poor ecosystem.
This brings us back to the Titans and Jeremiyah Love. Tennessee's current offensive infrastructure raises significant red flags. Their offensive line is in a state of flux, and the overall offensive identity lacks the stability and firepower seen in places like Detroit. Drafting a running back in the top five is a massive investment of draft capital, and for it to pay off, the surrounding pieces must be in place to unlock that player's generational potential.
For the Titans, the smarter play is to use the No. 4 pick to address a more foundational position—like offensive tackle or a game-changing pass rusher—that can elevate the entire team. Building from the trenches out creates the very environment where a star running back, whether acquired later in the draft or in future seasons, can truly dominate. In the high-stakes game of the NFL Draft, the right pick isn't always about the best player; it's about the best player for your team's situation. For Tennessee, that player at No. 4 is not Jeremiyah Love.