When the Indianapolis Colts used their second-to-last pick in the 2026 NFL Draft on Kentucky running back Seth McGowan, they added a player with a unique blend of power and versatility to their backfield. Let's break down what the experts are saying about this intriguing prospect.

McGowan's college career was a tale of two standout seasons. After rushing for 730 yards at New Mexico in 2024, he transferred to the SEC and posted an impressive 824 yards on the ground for Kentucky in 2025. His ability to contribute in the passing game was equally notable, with 64 total targets over those two seasons, according to Pro Football Focus.

Colts general manager Chris Ballard was quick to highlight the "physical element" McGowan brings to the position. That toughness should serve him well as he battles second-year back DJ Giddens for the primary backup role behind the starter. While ball security and running ability are prerequisites, the deciding factors in this competition could come down to special teams contributions and pass protection reliability.

So, what do the draft analysts think? Here's a closer look at the scouting reports:

The Upside: "McGowan has the build and athleticism to be a starting-caliber back at the NFL level. His explosiveness in short areas and long speed, paired with quick processing and play speed, make him a difference-maker between the tackles in power-run concepts."

The Concerns: "McGowan is quick to process and has enough wiggle to create when needed. However, his lack of explosive carries and fumble totals are concerning. McGowan is effective in short-yardage situations and flashes the skill to handle backup carries, but his age and lack of third-down value could work against him on draft day."

For Colts fans, McGowan represents a high-upside addition who could carve out a meaningful role if he addresses those concerns. Keep an eye on how this competition unfolds in training camp.