The San Jose Sharks are facing a pivotal decision with the No. 2 overall pick in the upcoming NHL Draft, and hockey analyst Craig Button has weighed in on the debate. The central question: Should they target forward Ivar Stenberg or defenseman Chase Reid?
Button didn't shy away from the tough questions. When asked if he'd take Reid over top prospect Gavin McKenna—should Toronto pass on him—Button made it clear that Reid is his standout defenseman for the 2026 Draft class. But the competition is stiff, with names like Keaton Verhoeff, Carson Carels, Alberts Smits, and Daxon Rudolph also in the mix.
The discussion also turned to 2025 prospects, with Button comparing Ivar Stenberg and Caleb Malhotra. Could Malhotra be a fit for the Sharks? And would Button consider trading that coveted No. 2 pick for a proven star NHL defenseman? He even shared a potential target for San Jose's later first-round picks at No. 19 or 20.
Button also reflected on the rookie seasons of Michael Misa and Sam Dickinson, while expressing optimism about Leo Sahlin Wallenius and Eric Pohlkamp. For a Sharks team looking to build through the draft, these insights offer a glimpse into the future.
Later in the podcast, former NHL defenseman Dan Boyle and analyst Zubair Jeewanjee joined to discuss the playoffs. Boyle was particularly impressed by Quinn Hughes' performance and had no issue with Evan Bouchard being overlooked in Norris Trophy voting. He also shared his thoughts on potential free-agent target Darren Raddysh, a defenseman who could bolster the Sharks' blue line.
The conversation took a speculative turn when the panel debated trading the No. 2 pick for Columbus Blue Jackets star Zach Werenski. And of course, no Sharks talk is complete without addressing the rumors—Connor McDavid and Auston Matthews to San Jose? The panel weighed in on that speculation too.
On a lighter note, the team discussed an awkward moment involving Toronto Sun reporter Steve Simmons at the John Chayka press conference. Sharks insider Sheng Peng even recalled making rookie Macklin Celebrini walk off during a post-game presser and asking coach David Quinn about his job security three years ago.
As the off-season approaches, the Sharks are also eyeing realistic free-agent and trade targets on defense. Keegan McNally recently penned a great article on that topic, highlighting the team's needs. Peng also clarified why he didn't vote Celebrini No. 1 for the Hart Trophy, offering a more concise explanation this time around.
So, who should the Sharks pick at No. 2? The debate rages on, but one thing is clear: San Jose's future hinges on making the right call. Whether it's Stenberg, Reid, or a trade, the decision will shape the franchise for years to come.