The Pittsburgh Steelers' offense enters a pivotal offseason clouded by uncertainty at the game's most important position. With the future of veteran quarterback Aaron Rodgers still up in the air, the current depth chart of Mason Rudolph and Will Howard leaves significant questions for head coach Mike McCarthy to answer.
This quarterback conundrum is shaping the team's projected draft strategy. In a recent CBS Sports mock draft, analyst Mike Renner has the Steelers making a franchise-altering move: selecting Alabama quarterback Ty Simpson in the first round. Renner suggests McCarthy was hired specifically to succeed where Mike Tomlin sometimes struggled—developing a young quarterback—and that Simpson's early-season flashes before injury show the raw tools to build upon.
However, the draft decision is far from straightforward. The general consensus views Simpson as a talent more likely to be taken late in the first round, potentially by a team trading up like the New York Jets or Arizona Cardinals. This leaves Pittsburgh with a critical choice: reach for Simpson and hope he avoids the path of previous first-round QB Kenny Pickett, or roll with the unproven Will Howard in 2026 and target a quarterback in the following draft.
Ultimately, the Steelers' direction hinges on two major factors: Mike McCarthy's conviction in a prospect like Simpson, and the final decision on Aaron Rodgers' playing future. One thing is certain: Pittsburgh's choice under center will define their trajectory for years to come.
