The NFL Draft is just two weeks away, and the mock draft machine is in overdrive. While most projections paint an optimistic picture for every team, let's flip the script. For the Pittsburgh Steelers, a franchise with a proud history and a fanbase hungry for a return to contention, draft day could go sideways. Here’s a look at a worst-case scenario for the Steelers' first three picks—a draft haul that would leave the Terrible Towels feeling a little less terrible and a lot more confused.
With the 20th overall pick, the nightmare begins: selecting an edge rusher. The Steelers already boast a deep and talented group featuring T.J. Watt, Alex Highsmith, Nick Herbig, and rookie standout Jeremiah Moon. Using a premium pick on another pass rusher, like UCLA's Laiatu Latu or Florida State's Jared Verse, would be a baffling misallocation of resources when glaring needs exist at wide receiver, offensive tackle, and in the secondary.
If the Steelers pivot to tackle in the first round, it could still be a misstep. While Broderick Jones's health is a question mark, reaching for a prospect like Oklahoma's Tyler Guyton over a top-tier receiver like Georgia's Ladd McConkey or a playmaking safety would fail to address the most pressing offensive issue: replacing Diontae Johnson's production and giving Russell Wilson a reliable new weapon.
The second round brings another potential blunder: quarterback. While the Steelers need to plan for the future behind Wilson, using a Day Two pick on a project like LSU's Garrett Nussmeier would be a luxury they can't afford. This roster needs immediate contributors, not a developmental passer with clear limitations from his 2025 season.
Closing out Day Two by drafting a tight end would compound the errors. Yes, the room is thin after Jonnu Smith's release, but using a valuable third-round pick on a player like Ohio State's Gee Scott Jr. ignores the far greater need for a starting-caliber center or a dynamic slot receiver. A tight end can be found later; impact players at premium positions cannot.
Ultimately, a Steelers draft class headlined by redundant edge rushers, questionable tackles, and project players would be a disaster. For a team in "win-now" mode, every selection must fortify the lineup. The true nightmare isn't missing on one pick—it's a systematic failure to address the roster's core weaknesses, leaving the Black and Gold ill-equipped for the brutal AFC North battle ahead.
