Mel Kiper mock draft: Caleb Downs over Sonny Styles for NY Giants at No. 5

2 min read
Mel Kiper mock draft: Caleb Downs over Sonny Styles for NY Giants at No. 5

Mel Kiper mock draft: Caleb Downs over Sonny Styles for NY Giants at No. 5

Mel Kiper mock draft: Caleb Downs over Sonny Styles for NY Giants at No. 5

Mel Kiper mock draft: Caleb Downs over Sonny Styles for NY Giants at No. 5

Mel Kiper's latest 2026 NFL mock draft is here, and it's a two-rounder that throws a fascinating curveball for the New York Giants. With the fifth overall pick, Kiper projects the Giants to pass on the popular choice, linebacker Sonny Styles, in favor of his Ohio State teammate, safety Caleb Downs. This isn't just a simple preference; Kiper frames it as a prediction of what the team *will* do, based on insider conversations about team needs and evaluations.

It sets up a compelling draft-day dilemma for Big Blue, who would have three elite Buckeyes in play. While wide receiver Carnell Tate could be a perfect complement to Malik Nabers, and Sonny Styles could quarterback the defense from the middle, Kiper is drawn to the transformative potential of Downs in the secondary. Pairing his incredible instincts with a star like Jevon Holland could create a devastating back end for the Giants' defense.

This pick would carry historical weight, making Downs the first safety drafted in the top five since Eric Berry in 2010. Kiper acknowledges that most analysts, mock drafts, and even oddsmakers lean toward Styles, a choice he often makes himself in weekly exercises. However, he circles back to the influence of head coach John Harbaugh and defensive coordinator Dennard Wilson.

Harbaugh's history with legendary safeties—from Brian Dawkins to Ed Reed and Kyle Hamilton—combined with Wilson's own background as a defensive back, suggests a front office that deeply values the position. While Styles offers immense athletic upside, the allure of building the new defensive identity around a cerebral playmaker like Downs might be too strong for this regime to pass up.

Later in the second round, Kiper has the Giants addressing the offensive line with Georgia guard Dylan Rutledge, a durable and reliable prospect who could start immediately. The mock also notes a potential "what-if" scenario, as defensive tackle Kayden McDonald—another Ohio State star—came off the board just before the Giants' second pick, a selection that might have gained even more intrigue following recent news about Dexter Lawrence.

Like this article?

Order custom jerseys for your team with free design

Related Topics

Related News

Back to All News