In a move that surprised even the star player herself, Maddy Shirley has added one final, historic honor to her already legendary basketball career. On Wednesday, Central High School announced that Shirley will become the first basketball player in school history to have her jersey retired—a moment that cements her legacy not just in the record books, but in the heart of the program.
Head coach David Alexander revealed that the idea first sparked midway through last season. While there were still milestones to check off, he knew that Shirley’s impact—both statistically and culturally—made this the perfect moment to honor what she meant to the Bears. “She did everything right from day one,” Alexander said. “The production on the floor and statistics show that. The wins show that. When you own half the record book and won with it, you’ve cemented yourself in the history of our program.”
From now on, no one will wear No. 32 for Central girls basketball again. An official retirement ceremony will take place during a home game next season, with the date yet to be announced. Shirley, a University of Southern Indiana signee, finishes her career tied for 38th in Indiana state history with 2,113 points—second all-time in Evansville—along with 1,069 rebounds. She is one of just 13 female players in state history to achieve that rare points-rebounds double. At Central, she holds program records for points, rebounds, blocks, and numerous other categories.
Her accolades read like a highlight reel: Junior All-Star, two-time Supreme 15 All-State selection, and three-time Courier & Press Metro Player of the Year. She led the Bears to three sectional championships and the program’s first regional title in 2025. Her 46-point outburst against No. 1 Greensburg in the semi-state ranks tied for eighth in IHSAA postseason history—a performance that showcased her ability to rise to the biggest moments.
Shirley was called into principal Andrew Freeman’s office on Wednesday, completely unaware of the honor awaiting her. A display case featuring her jersey will soon be constructed inside the gymnasium—a permanent reminder of a player who didn’t just rewrite the record book, but redefined what’s possible for Central basketball. For fans and future Bears, No. 32 will always stand for excellence.