The New York Yankees have called up Anthony Volpe to fill in at shortstop while Jose Caballero recovers from a fractured right middle finger. While fan reactions to Volpe are mixed—especially after a 2025 season marred by defensive miscues—fantasy baseball managers are eyeing his potential value during this temporary stint.

Volpe's fantasy history is a rollercoaster. His best campaign came in 2024, when he posted a modest .243 batting average but contributed 12 home runs and 28 stolen bases, making him a mid-to-low-end shortstop option. In 2025, his average dipped to .212, though he still managed 19 homers and 18 steals, once again landing in that same tier. Importantly, most fantasy formats don't penalize fielding errors, so his defensive struggles won't hurt your roster.

If you're considering adding Volpe, manage expectations: he's not a high-upside, every-day starter. Instead, think of him as a solid utility piece who can provide depth. The Yankees have been thrilled with Caballero's elite defense this season, and manager Aaron Boone has made it clear Caballero remains the team's shortstop long-term. Once he returns from the 10-day IL—likely in about a week, barring setbacks—Volpe will shift back to a bench role.

Still, for fantasy managers in need of shortstop depth or stolen base help, Volpe is worth a short-term add. His experience and past production offer a reliable floor, even if the ceiling isn't sky-high.