NASHVILLE, Tenn. — Maya Johnson remembers every slight, even the ones that came from the people closest to her. The Belmont senior pitcher and All-American can still rattle off the schools that didn't recruit her out of Columbia Station, Ohio. She'll never forget how Pittsburgh, the one program that took a chance on her, refused to clear her to play as a freshman because of her struggles with lupus — a chronic autoimmune disease diagnosed when she was just 15.
Her mother, Kristen Johnson, begged her to come home and rest after that first semester of college. Her father, Ryan Johnson, tried to keep her pitching ambitions grounded as the left-hander dreamed of being the best while managing her condition.
"She'll still put that in my face every once in a while, like, 'Dad, remember when you didn't believe in me?'" Ryan Johnson said with a laugh. "No, that was not the crux of what I was saying!"
That chip-on-the-shoulder mentality has fueled Johnson's remarkable rise. Before facing Illinois State in last weekend's MVC tournament, head coach Laura Matthews reminded Johnson that the Redbirds are a high-contact team. They had scratched out eight hits and two runs in April, striking out just eight times, handing Johnson one of her two losses this season. The message: prepare to miss fewer bats and don't get frustrated.
Johnson responded with 17 strikeouts and a two-hit shutout. After the game, she found Matthews in the dugout with a smirk: "They're gonna put the ball in play, huh?"
"My favorite athlete of all time is Michael Jordan, so I think it's sacrilegious to compare him to anybody," Matthews said. "But you know how he always had that 'Nobody believes in me, everyone's against me' mindset, no matter what? That's Maya. Last week, she was talking about how much she has to prove."
Johnson, who will lead Belmont against Southeastern Louisiana in Friday's Tuscaloosa Regional opener, turned down hundreds of thousands of dollars in NIL opportunities to stay at the small Nashville program. It's a decision that speaks volumes about loyalty, grit, and the belief that sometimes the best path isn't the most obvious one. For a pitcher who has spent her entire career proving people wrong, staying at Belmont was just another way to write her own story.
