Who truly rules the diamond in Northeast Florida baseball history? That's the question we're putting to you, our readers, as we celebrate the region's all-time greats. With the United States approaching its 250th anniversary this summer, USA TODAY Sports is honoring the 250 most influential American sports figures ever. As part of this national tribute, we're shining a spotlight on the athletes who defined their communities—and right here on the First Coast, that means some legendary baseball talent.
This honor is part of a series rolling out through 2026, selected by a panel of USA TODAY Network experts from across the state. But we want your voice to be heard, too. So, we've narrowed it down to 10 standout stars—listed in alphabetical order—who not only dominated at the high school level in Jacksonville and Northeast Florida but went on to achieve greatness beyond. These are the players who made their mark on the field and in the record books.
Let's take a closer look at two of the nominees who exemplify the depth of local talent:
Javier Báez put up jaw-dropping numbers at the now-closed Arlington Country Day School, posting a .771 batting average as a senior with 20 doubles, six triples, 22 home runs, 52 RBI, and 28 stolen bases. Drafted ninth overall in the first round, "El Mago" has dazzled in a 13-year MLB career, earning three All-Star selections, a 2016 World Series title with the Chicago Cubs, and 1,225 hits with 191 home runs. His versatility earned him a Gold Glove in 2020, and he finished second in NL MVP voting in 2018 after a .290 season with 40 doubles, 34 homers, and 111 RBI. Plus, he was the 2016 NLCS MVP—talk about a big-game performer!
Vince Coleman was the most feared base-stealer in the National League during the mid-to-late 1980s. A standout at Raines High School, Coleman won two pennants with the St. Louis Cardinals and made two All-Star teams. His 752 stolen bases rank sixth all-time in MLB, including six consecutive stolen base titles and three seasons with 100 or more steals. He was named NL Rookie of the Year in 1985 and finished his career with a .264 average, 1,425 hits, and 849 runs scored. An all-around athlete, Coleman was also a nationally recruited punter at Florida A&M and even spent time in an NFL mini-camp with Washington.
These are just two of the 10 nominees that represent the best of Northeast Florida baseball. Ready to cast your vote? Click the link below and help decide who takes the crown as the all-time best from the First Coast!