Section 4 high school football has long been a proving ground for some of the nation's most dominant programs and unforgettable athletes. From record-breaking performances to legendary careers, the players who have suited up here have left an indelible mark on their communities and beyond.

Now, as the USA TODAY Network celebrates top athletes across the country in honor of America's 250th anniversary, we're turning the spotlight on the very best to ever take the field in New York's Southern Tier. The question is simple: Who is the greatest prep football player in Section 4 history?

We've narrowed down thousands of standout athletes to just five finalists, but we know that football is a team sport where greatness can come from any school, any size, any era. That's why we're giving you the chance to vote—or even write in your own pick for the ultimate champion.

Our selections are based primarily on high school achievements, records, team impact, and the sheer level of talent on display, though college and pro accomplishments were also considered. You can find the poll online at stargazette.com.

Among the nominees is a name that echoes through history: Ernie Davis, known as the Elmira Express. The nickname, coined by Star-Gazette sports writer Al Mallette during Davis's time at Elmira Free Academy, lives on today as the school's mascot and inspired the 2008 film The Express.

Davis began his high school career at offensive and defensive end before moving to halfback as a junior. In just 13 games over the 1956 and '57 seasons, he rushed for 1,314 yards on 179 carries—an incredible 7.4 yards per attempt—and scored 21 touchdowns. He was also a basketball star, leading EFA to a 52-game winning streak.

After graduating in 1958, Davis went on to Syracuse University, where he helped the Orange win a national championship in 1959 and took home the Heisman Trophy as college football's top player in 1961. Selected first overall in the 1962 NFL draft, his life was tragically cut short by leukemia in May 1963 at just 23 years old.

Now it's your turn to decide: Which Section 4 legend deserves the crown?