As the calendar flips to May, fantasy baseball managers are getting a clearer picture of who's for real and who's just a hot start. Our latest Shuffle Up series dives deep into the middle infield, where shortstops and second basemen are making their cases for roster spots. Whether you're looking to buy low, sell high, or just figure out where your team stands, these updated rankings based on a fresh draft-day salary approach will help you navigate the diamond.

Think of these salaries as a comparison tool, not a final verdict. Players at the same tier are considered even, so don't get stuck on the dollar signs. What matters is the performance so far—and what we expect going forward. Most Yahoo-eligible second basemen and shortstops are included here, minus anyone on the IL or in the minors. Have a different take? That's what makes this game great. Share your thoughts on X or Bluesky.

Let's start with the superstars. Bobby Witt Jr. might have some managers worried, but here's the truth: trade him to me. His average and steals are right where they should be, and there's no reason to think he won't finish with 20-30 homers. He's still the fastest player in baseball and in his prime. Patience is key.

Elly De La Cruz is another name causing buzz. After his power disappeared in the second half last year, he's come back with a vengeance. His plate discipline is better than most realize—chase rate and walk rate are solid, and his strikeout rate is trending down. Plus, his hard-hit profile is as fiery as his Reds uniform. This is a superstar spreading his wings.

Fernando Tatís Jr. now has second-base eligibility, giving you serious lineup flexibility. A home run might be just around the corner. His expected average sits at .280 and expected slugging at .402—he's been unlucky so far. His line drive rate has actually improved, so the power surge is coming. Stay patient.

Jazz Chisholm Jr. still has a strikeout problem, even with acceptable walk and chase rates. You can look at it two ways: either you appreciate the raw talent and hope he cuts down on the whiffs, or you worry about the inconsistency. Either way, he's a dynamic talent worth monitoring closely.

Whether you're building for a championship run or just trying to stay competitive, these middle infield rankings can guide your next move. Keep an eye on the stats, trust the process, and remember—May is still early enough to make a big impact.