The Pittsburgh Steelers head into the 2026 NFL Draft in a strong position, thanks to a busy and strategic offseason. With the first round on the horizon, the big question is: which player will they select? While the front office holds the final cards, we've tapped into the collective wisdom of the NFL community to see who fans and analysts are predicting. Using data from thousands of mock drafts run through a popular simulator, here are the ten most popular projections for the Steelers' first-round pick.
Based on the data, a clear top tier of prospects emerges. If we were to rank them, our top five from this list would be Vega, Fano, Cooper, Sadiq, and Lemon. These players represent the most compelling fits and value for Pittsburgh at their draft slot, with a noticeable gap between them and the next group. Several other names on the list seem like reaches for the first round, at least based on current team needs and draft capital.
The most intriguing name among the popular picks is Alabama quarterback Ty Simpson. However, recent statements from ownership, head coach Mike McCarthy, and local reports suggest the quarterback room will be led by Aaron Rodgers and Will Howard. This likely takes the Steelers out of the market for a signal-caller with their precious first-round selection, making other positions like offensive line, cornerback, or pass rusher far more probable targets.