Steelers Rookie Drew Allar Getting Compared to Super Bowl Winning QB is a Good & Bad Thing

3 min read
Steelers Rookie Drew Allar Getting Compared to Super Bowl Winning QB is a Good & Bad Thing

Steelers Rookie Drew Allar Getting Compared to Super Bowl Winning QB is a Good & Bad Thing

Steelers Rookie Drew Allar Getting Compared to Super Bowl Winning QB is a Good & Bad Thing

Steelers Rookie Drew Allar Getting Compared to Super Bowl Winning QB is a Good & Bad Thing

The Pittsburgh Steelers may have their quarterback of the future in rookie Drew Allar—and according to a new report, the young signal-caller is drawing comparisons to a Super Bowl-winning quarterback. But as with any comparison, there are both highs and lows to consider.

All signs point to the Steelers eventually signing future Hall of Famer Aaron Rodgers as their starter for the 2026 season. But that didn't stop the franchise from investing in the position during last month's NFL Draft. With the 76th overall pick in the third round, Pittsburgh selected Penn State quarterback Drew Allar—a move that speaks volumes about the upside the team sees in him, especially considering he played in just six games last season after breaking his ankle.

On a recent edition of SportsCenter, ESPN's Jeremy Fowler dropped an intriguing nugget: one Steelers official reportedly said Allar "reminds them of a young Joe Flacco." That's heady company, considering Flacco led the Baltimore Ravens to a Super Bowl victory in 2012 and has enjoyed an 18-year NFL career.

So, what's the Steelers brass seeing in Allar? They love his size, his football IQ, and his NFL-ready arm. The knocks on his game? Decision-making in the heat of the moment and footwork that needs refinement. But the organization is optimistic that new head coach Mike McCarthy—known for his quarterback development chops—can help Allar iron out those wrinkles and eventually become a starter.

Being compared to Flacco is a double-edged sword. On one hand, Flacco has hung around the league for nearly two decades, playing for six teams and making multiple playoff runs. His cannon arm has kept him employed well into his 40s. But fans also remember the less glamorous side of Flacco's game: double-digit interceptions were a yearly tradition during his prime, and he only threw 25 or more touchdowns in a season twice. Since 2018, he's settled into a role as one of the league's most reliable backups—a testament to his short-term value, but also a reminder that his flaws tend to surface over time.

For Steelers fans, the Allar-Flacco comparison is a mixed bag. It signals promise and potential, but also carries a warning about the limitations that come with that playing style. The key will be how McCarthy and the coaching staff develop Allar's decision-making and footwork—turning those weaknesses into strengths before he's asked to lead the offense.

Like this article?

Order custom jerseys for your team with free design

Related Topics

Related News

Back to All News