Section 1 discusses litigation to compel NYSPHSAA to change postseason

3 min read
Section 1 discusses litigation to compel NYSPHSAA to change postseason

Section 1 discusses litigation to compel NYSPHSAA to change postseason

Section 1 is moving forward with a constitutional amendment proposal that may lead to the exit of four private schools while discussing legal action.

Section 1 discusses litigation to compel NYSPHSAA to change postseason

Section 1 is moving forward with a constitutional amendment proposal that may lead to the exit of four private schools while discussing legal action.

Big changes could be coming to high school sports in New York's Section 1, and the conversation is heating up both in boardrooms and potentially in courtrooms. This week, the Athletic Council took a major step forward by approving a ballot measure that would create separate postseason tournaments for public and private schools—a move that could reshape the competitive landscape for years to come.

The proposal, which would require a constitutional amendment, has been a long time coming. For nearly two years, administrators across the state have debated whether private schools—which can draw athletes from a wide geographic area—should compete for the same sectional and state championships as public schools, whose talent pools are limited by district boundaries. The issue has only intensified after dominant runs by teams like the Albertus Magnus girls basketball squad and the CBA-Syracuse football team, both of which recently secured state championship threepeats. With 89 non-public school members currently in the New York State Public High School Athletic Association (NYSPHSAA), the tension is palpable.

Section 1 officials aren't just waiting for the state to act, though. They're now discussing legal action to compel NYSPHSAA to level the playing field. "We don't want to go to litigation, but it might be necessary at some point," said Marc Baiocco, Section 1 president and superintendent of Clarkstown Schools. A lawsuit from a member section against the state association would be highly unusual—NYSPHSAA executive director Robert Zayas noted, "I've been doing this for 14 years and we have not been sued by one of our member sections." He added that he would be "very curious what the claim would be," but the association is prepared to defend itself.

For now, Section 1 is moving forward with a referendum that could ultimately lead to the departure of four private schools in the section: Albertus Magnus, Ursuline, Leffell, and Keio. While the Athletic Council approved creating a ballot on Tuesday, local administrators are still holding out hope that NYSPHSAA might reverse course and enact meaningful change without a fight. Whether that happens or not, one thing is clear—the debate over fairness in high school sports is far from over, and the outcome could set a precedent for the entire state.

Like this article?

Order custom jerseys for your team with free design

Related Topics

Related News

Back to All News
Section 1 discusses litigation to compel NYSPHSAA to change postseason | Latest Sports News & Analysis | Ballerna