Roy Keane, the legendary former Manchester United captain and Premier League midfield enforcer, has shared a major concern about Michael Carrick potentially taking over as the club's permanent manager—and it's got fans talking.

After steering United back into the Champions League with a thrilling 3-2 victory over arch-rivals Liverpool, Carrick has earned widespread praise. Many supporters and ex-players are now backing the caretaker boss to land the job full-time, believing the former England international could usher in a bright new era at Old Trafford.

United need just four points from their remaining three Premier League games to secure a third-place finish—their highest since 2023. Few predicted such a dramatic turnaround when Carrick took the reins in January, with the team struggling for consistency and positive results.

Since his appointment, Carrick has masterminded statement wins over both Manchester City and Arsenal, while his side has collected 32 points from 14 games—the best record of any Premier League team in that stretch. Individual performances have also soared. Kobbie Mainoo, fresh off signing a new long-term contract, delivered a match-winning display against Liverpool, scoring the decisive goal. Meanwhile, Bruno Fernandes has rediscovered his best form, climbing United's all-time assist charts after Carrick pushed him further up the pitch—a tactical tweak that's unlocked his full potential.

But not everyone is convinced. Roy Keane, speaking on The Overlap podcast, voiced his reservations about Carrick's credentials. While acknowledging the logic behind the growing support, Keane questioned whether the former midfielder has the experience to handle the immense pressure of managing United long-term, especially with the challenges that next season will bring.

As the debate heats up, one thing is clear: Carrick has transformed this squad from a side in disarray into a force to be reckoned with. Whether that's enough to win over Keane—and the Old Trafford hierarchy—remains to be seen.