With the NFL draft hours away, the buzz is growing about the Dallas Cowboys trading up in the first round to get a star defensive player. From local beat writers to national analysts, most of the final mock drafts have Dallas moving into the top ten to select either Caleb Downs, Sonny Styles, or Mansoor Delane. At the end of the day, the Cowboys could be walking away with one of those three players.
It would be the first time Dallas has traded up in the first round for a player since Morris Claiborne in 2012. The last three times the Cowboys have moved off their original pick on night one of the draft, it’s been to trade down and collect more capital. However, in a draft like this where the premier talent does not stretch to 12th overall, Jerry Jones, Stephen Jones, and Will McClay might have to be aggressive if they want to get an impact player.
Since 2007, the Cowboys have traded first-round picks on the night of the draft seven times. Let’s rank them in honor of it potentially happening again. (author’s note: these rankings don’t take into account draft capital value; it’s more about how the careers of the players turned out)
There’s no way we can make a list about first-round trades and not mention the ‘What If?’ trade for Paxton Lynch. The Cowboys were aiming for the heir apparent to Tony Romo after he missed most of the 2015 season with a collarbone injury, tanking another shot at the postseason. His body was starting to break down, and the Cowboys needed to find their next franchise quarterback.
Dallas had the fourth overall pick in the draft, so they did a ton of research on the top quarterbacks in the class. All three of the top prospects were brought in for a 30-visit—Jared Goff, Carson Wentz, and Paxton Lynch. Goff and Wentz went first and second overall, and Dallas selected Ezekiel Elliott instead of Jalen Ramsey. But Dallas wanted another swing for the fences in the first round and tried trading back into the mix for Lynch.
The Cowboys were competing with the Denver Broncos for Lynch and lost out because they were unwilling to offer more valuable picks in the trade. Instead, Dallas was forced to pivot to plan C after missing out on Connor Cook and selecting Dak Prescott in the fourth round.
There’s no telling how Lynch’s career would have gone having been in Dallas instead of Denver. The shadow of Tony Romo would not have been as big as the one Peyton Manning left with the Broncos, forcing Lynch to live up to those expectations. But given how their careers have played out, the Cowboys lucked out in having Prescott fall into their laps. The last decade of the franchise would look vastly different if this trade had been pulled off.
Unfortunately, Jerry Jones’ biggest move over the last two decades on draft night might be his worst. The Cowboys were aggressive and went after one of the draft’s premier defenders (sound familiar?) in Claiborne to be a modern-day Deion Sanders.
Claiborne’s start in Dallas could almost summarize the rest of his career with the team, needing surgery on his wrist before even taking a single snap after he was drafted. From there, Claibrone would only be available for 47 out of the 85 regular-season games over five years. To make things worse, for a player who was supposed to be a ballhawking cornerback, Claiborne had a total of four interceptions.
Dallas’ aggression was applauded in 2012, but it is the reason why some are scared to see the Cowboys move up in this year’s draft. To potentially select another cornerback from LSU, no less. You would hope Jerry Jones has learned from his past mistake and makes sure whoever they trade up for is a more sure thing than the return they got with Claiborne.
The Cowboys were looking for help along their offensive line after they decided not to re-sign Tyron Smith and Tyler Biadasz in the same offseason. While on the clock in the first round, Dallas got the offer to move back with the Detroit Lions, who were coming up for cornerback Terrion Arnold.
Dallas felt comfortable moving back and still landing a player they would have taken at No. 24. Then Jordan Morgan and Graham Barton went to the Green Bay Packers and the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, both of whom Dallas showed significant interest in. They were still happy to land Tyler Guyton at pick 29 with the hope he could be their future left tackle.
There was no question Guyton was going to need some room to grow as a rookie being new to left tackle. The Cowboys’ first-round pick did get the start right away, and his first professional game was against Myles Garrett and the Cleveland Browns.
Guyton has shown flashes over two years of becoming the player Dallas hoped he would be, but his health and penalty issues raise bigger questions about where the Cowboys might go at the position in the future. If Guyton can put things together this year and show signs of being a franchise left tackle, then there’s a chance he can be much higher on this list in the future. But for right now, it’s wait and see.
After already selecting Felix Jones in the first round (originally the Cleveland Browns’ pick), Dallas wanted to get a lockdown cornerback on the outside to pair with Terence Newman and give the defense an A-plus secondary. After a solid rookie season, Jenkins turned on the heat in his sophomore season, made a Pro Bowl, and looked like he would become a future All-Pro.
Unfortunately, Jenkins will always be a one-hit wonder, and his career never matched what he showed in 2009. He was with the Cowboys for just three more seasons before he moved on to the then-Oakland Raiders. Outside of David Irving, Jenkins will remain one of the biggest what-if players in team history.
The Cowboys gave up the 22nd overall pick to the Cleveland Browns so they could draft their next franchise quarterback in Brady Quinn. From a value standpoint, this is one of Dallas’ more favorable moves, considering they got a future first-round pick out of the deal and got enough capital to trade back into the first round and take Anthony Spencer at 26th overall.
2007 ended up being one of the best seasons in franchise history since the 90’s Cowboys, but Spencer didn’t have to do much as a rookie stepping into an already stacked defense ready to go. Headlined by DeMarcus Ware and an aging Greg Ellis, Spencer fell into the perfect situation to learn from the best.
Over the years in Dallas, Spencer never became a household name as a defensive end/outside linebacker, but was as consistent a player as you could hope for at that position. Spencer was also famous for being the first player in franchise history to receive the franchise tag twice.
Spencer spent his entire eight-year career with the Cowboys and finished with 33 career sacks, the 15th-best in team history.