Pistons’ stunning Game 1 defeat wasn’t Magic pulling rabbit out of hat

5 min read
Pistons’ stunning Game 1 defeat wasn’t Magic pulling rabbit out of hat - Image 1
Pistons’ stunning Game 1 defeat wasn’t Magic pulling rabbit out of hat - Image 2
Pistons’ stunning Game 1 defeat wasn’t Magic pulling rabbit out of hat - Image 3
Pistons’ stunning Game 1 defeat wasn’t Magic pulling rabbit out of hat - Image 4

Pistons’ stunning Game 1 defeat wasn’t Magic pulling rabbit out of hat

The Pistons showed why it's really hard to trust them after the Magic bullied them in Detroit.

Pistons’ stunning Game 1 defeat wasn’t Magic pulling rabbit out of hat

The Pistons showed why it's really hard to trust them after the Magic bullied them in Detroit.

Article image
Article image
Article image

I realize I'm going against the grain here, but I'm about to say something "controversial."

The Detroit Pistons' tremendous regular-season success this year wasn't, in fact, fake.

You heard me. You don't win 60 games, the first time Detroit has achieved that in 20 years, and capture the Eastern Conference's No. 1 seed if you're built on a house of cards. You're not tied for second in net rating, with the league's No. 2 defense, and still a pretender. The Pistons, for all intents and purposes, were and remain a wagon.

But there's a big difference between the grind of regular-season basketball and the intensity of the playoffs. The Pistons showed us as much in their dispiriting 112-101 Game 1 defeat to the Orlando Magic on Sunday night.

To be clear, I'm not here to sound the alarms about Detroit losing the series. Well, at least not yet. But you have to know how rare it is to see a No. 8 seed win Game 1 on the road. These are massive upsets, dearest readers! Since 1984, only 14 teams in the same position have ever managed such a feat, with the last coming in 2023 when the underdog Miami Heat upended the Milwaukee Bucks to open their playoff matchup. Of course, not every road Game 1 winner over a top seed went on to win the series. That's only ever happened six times because, you know, No. 1 vs. No. 8 is usually supposed to amount to a sweep or gentleman's sweep for the favorite.

So, if we put on our deductive reasoning caps, such opening losses for the top dog are usually a sign that something is missing.

In the Pistons' case, it's that they clearly don't have enough firepower.

What happens when Cade Cunningham is the only one who can get a bucket when Detroit needs it? What happens when you don't have enough perimeter shooting to unclog the paint against a playoff-caliber defense? What happens when a similarly offensively-challenged team can match your physicality and size in a way few other active playoff contenders are even capable of? What happens when the opposing teams can dictate the terms of engagement because, at your core, you're pretty one-dimensional when it comes to putting the ball through the net?

You lose Game 1 at home, convincingly, with the Pistons' faithful still waiting to see their first home playoff win since (checks notes) 2008? Woof.

I don't think the Pistons are going to lose this series to Orlando. In fact, I would be shocked. Perhaps the Magic are riding some sort of unexpected postseason wave, but I'm willing to bet they will eventually fall back to Earth and play like the inconsistent middling team they were for most of the regular season.

Even still, I'm concerned. To me, Game 1 was a warning sign about what this version of the Pistons is really capable of. If they couldn't keep up with the plodding, shaky Magic, I can't imagine they could do much better against Donovan Mitchell and James Harden, or Jalen Brunson and Karl-Anthony Towns, or Jayson Tatum and Jaylen Brown. You get the idea.

On paper, Orlando is supposed to be a warm-up for the East's real heavyweights, not a daunting test of Detroit's mettle. It's not supposed to be in a dogfight just yet. And if it loses Game 2 at home to fall down 0-2? That's full-on crisis territory for a young core that has yet to win a playoff series.

We're about to learn a lot about the Pistons over the next week or so. Something tells me we've already seen enough to know these Pistons, with glaring red flags, don't have the chops to make it to June the way they think they might.

Trail Blazers owner Tom Dundon shouldn't have bought the team if he was going to pinch pennies in the silliest ways.

My guy Prince Grimes says LeBron James really should have an Irish goodbye to the NBA.

Victor Wembanyama is the first-ever unanimous Defensive Player of the Year ... in Year 3. He doesn't need seemingly made-up stats to make him look more impressive.

Speaking of the Spurs, their Game 1 arena color coordination looked incredible.

This was Layup Lines, For the Win's basketball newsletter. Subscribe here to get it delivered to your inbox every Monday, Wednesday, and Friday.

This article originally appeared on For The Win: Pistons show alarming red flags in concerning Game 1 loss to Magic

Like this article?

Order custom jerseys for your team with free design

Related Topics

Related News

Back to All News