The AFC East just got a new quarterback to watch—and he’s already making headlines for all the wrong reasons. Miami Dolphins QB Malik Willis stepped up to throw the ceremonial first pitch at the Miami Marlins’ game on Friday, and let’s just say it didn’t go as planned. The result? A pitch so wild it sailed high and away, hitting the backstop instead of the catcher’s glove. Ouch.

Now, we all know throwing a baseball is different from launching a football. Even star quarterbacks can struggle when they trade the gridiron for the diamond. But here’s the thing: Willis gets paid to throw a ball. So when he airmails a pitch like that, the internet doesn’t hold back. The clip has already gone viral, and you can bet it’ll resurface every time he misses a target this season. Willis later commented on Instagram that he slipped—hey, it happens. But in the world of sports, memes are forever.

Still, let’s keep some perspective. The Dolphins didn’t sign Willis to throw baseballs; they brought him in to sling it on the field. After showing real improvement with the Green Bay Packers last season, he’s the kind of passer the New England Patriots will need to game-plan for. So while this first-pitch flub is good for a laugh, the real test comes when he’s under center. For now, though, it’s a reminder that even elite athletes can have an off day—and social media never forgets.

Whether you’re a Patriots fan enjoying the schadenfreude or a Dolphins supporter hoping Willis bounces back, one thing’s for sure: this is the kind of moment that makes sports so entertaining. And if you’re gearing up for the season, don’t forget to stock up on gear that helps you throw like a pro—not like this.