The NFL Draft is always a whirlwind of surprises, strategy, and speculation—but who better to break down the real winners and losers than the college coaches who spent years molding these players? They’ve seen the draftees up close, in the locker room and on the field, and their insider perspective offers a unique take on how teams fared.

This year, a few franchises stood out for their savvy moves. The Dallas Cowboys, New York Jets, and Arizona Cardinals all earned high marks from the college coaching community, which loved how these teams addressed key needs while scooping up undervalued talent. The Cowboys, in particular, were praised for landing a versatile playmaker who can step in immediately, while the Jets’ aggressive approach to fortifying their roster drew comparisons to a championship blueprint.

But not every decision was met with applause. Several picks left coaches scratching their heads, questioning whether teams reached for potential over proven production. One surprise early-round selection, in particular, sparked debate about whether a player’s college stats truly translate to the pro game—a reminder that even the best evaluators can be caught off guard.

For fans and fantasy owners alike, these insights are gold. Whether you’re stocking up on your team’s new rookie jersey or just sizing up the competition, understanding the draft’s hidden narratives can give you an edge. After all, the college coaches know these athletes best—and their verdict is in: some teams nailed it, while others left room for improvement.