The New York Giants entered the 2025 season with cautious optimism, but according to a recent NFL Roster Projection Model by analyst Austin Mock of The Athletic, the team is still facing an uphill climb. Mock's model, which uses advanced metrics to evaluate each player's impact against a replacement-level performer, ranked the Giants 26th out of 32 teams. The projected margin of victory against an average opponent sits at -2.5 points—a clear sign that the roster needs more work.

On the bright side, the Giants have some young stars to build around. Wide receiver Malik Nabers and edge rusher Abdul Carter have both turned heads early in their careers, showing the kind of explosive talent that can change a game. But beyond these bright spots, the roster has significant gaps that keep the team near the bottom of the league.

The biggest question mark is at quarterback. Rookie Jaxson Dart's first season has been labeled as "unspectacular" by Mock, leaving the future of the position uncertain. While Dart showed flashes, the consistency wasn't there, and the Giants now face a critical decision on whether he's the long-term answer under center.

Defensively, the problems are even more glaring. The interior defensive line is ranked dead last in the league, and the cornerback room isn't much better at 30th. Trading away star defensive tackle Dexter Lawrence was a tough blow, and despite adding veterans like D.J. Reader and Shelby Harris, the unit may have actually taken a step back. At cornerback, the team drafted Colton Hood in 2026 and plans to start him alongside veteran Paulson Adebo this season, but that duo will need time to gel.

For a team hoping to climb the NFC East standings, the Giants have their work cut out for them. With a few key pieces in place but plenty of holes to fill, the 2026 season will be a true test of how quickly this roster can develop—starting with Jaxson Dart's sophomore leap.