New York Giants' trade up, pick of Malachi Fields met with mixed reviews

4 min read
New York Giants' trade up, pick of Malachi Fields met with mixed reviews - Image 1
New York Giants' trade up, pick of Malachi Fields met with mixed reviews - Image 2
New York Giants' trade up, pick of Malachi Fields met with mixed reviews - Image 3
New York Giants' trade up, pick of Malachi Fields met with mixed reviews - Image 4

New York Giants' trade up, pick of Malachi Fields met with mixed reviews

The New York Giants' decision to trade-up for WR Malachi Fields has been met with reviews on the polar opposite sides.

New York Giants' trade up, pick of Malachi Fields met with mixed reviews

The New York Giants' decision to trade-up for WR Malachi Fields has been met with reviews on the polar opposite sides.

Article image
Article image
Article image

With the 74th pick in the 2026 NFL draft, the New York Giants selected wide receiver Malachi Fields out of Notre Dame. The Giants, of course, did not have a third-round pick, so they traded with the Cleveland Browns to land Fields.

The Giants had a strong opening two rounds of the draft but entered Day 2 without a third-round selection after trading the pick away last year to move up and select quarterback Jaxson Dart.

The team had been rumored to be looking for another weapon for Dart ahead of the second day of the draft, and they did just that by selecting Fields.

1 / 14New York Giants vs. Dallas Cowboys: Best photos from Week 18Dallas Cowboys (home, away)

Fields, a 6-foot-4, 218-pound receiver, caught 36 passes for 630 yards and five touchdowns in 2025. Over his college career at Virginia and Notre Dame, he totaled 165 receptions for 2,479 yards and 16 touchdowns.

While the Giants certainly needed to bolster their wide receiver corps, they prioritized other positions with their first three picks. The decision to trade up for Fields has drawn mixed reviews.

This is not your same ole Giants team…They’re having one of the best drafts in the league so far. ▪️Arvell Reese▪️Francis Mauigoa▪️Colton Hood▪️Malachi Fields

John Harbaugh says that Malachi Fields is consistently running over 21 MPH in fields, per the GPS data, which is comparable to a 4.4 40-yard dash. Fields ran a 4.61 at the NFL Combine. Not a concern for the #Giants. They believe his play speed is much faster.

74) NYG: Malachi Fields - WR/Notre DameFairly aggressive trade up for a wide receiver with a massive frame who gives the passing game a real Z receiver. Excellent downfield ball tracker who can finish. Physical enough to factor as a blocker. 30% of his catches over the last two…

Giants traded all that to take Malachi Fields? Lmao i remain thankful for that organization

Malachi Fields could star as the Giants' X-receiver opposite Malik Nabers 🔥(via @fantasysmyth) pic.twitter.com/er1LnNpyIv

— Yahoo Fantasy Sports (@YahooFantasy) April 25, 2026

The Giants passed on Christen Miller for Colten Hood then Chris McClellan for Malachi Fields. Clearly they're telling us they aren't as worried about the DT situation as fans might be. I don't see any way out of the hole they've dug other than signing Reader AND Harris/Calais

Giving up three draft picks for Malachi Fields feels like flawed process https://t.co/7awn1FAuxA

Malachi Fields will have a chance to make an impact this year for the Giants. #FFHappyHour @LordDontLose @rotoworld_fb pic.twitter.com/IzXjdZdDt7

There was an expectation the Giants would sign OBJ this Monday when the contract situations change and I think it was very likely to happen until a few minutes ago when they traded three picks to get Malachi Fields. It's still possible but not sure if it's as likely. We'll see.

John Harbaugh paid a real price for Malachi Fields, but he’s got to do everything he can to support Jaxson Dart, especially with Nabers & Skatt coming off major injuries. Fields joins Mauigoa, Likely, Ricard as new large humans on Giants offense in Harbaugh’s drive to play big.

Malachi Fields = unathletic Ramses Barden https://t.co/M9oGPZPhSj

Giants trading up for Malachi Fields while stars fly off the board? This is why the franchise is a joke. Enjoy watching Nabers get triple-covered while this guy drops passes.

— 𝔸𝔹𝔻𝕌𝕃 🥷🙂‍↔️ (@web3_prince2) April 25, 2026

Like this article?

Order custom jerseys for your team with free design

Related Topics

Related News

Back to All News