There's a poetic justice brewing in the football world, and it centers on James Garner. The 25-year-old midfielder left Manchester United without ever truly getting a chance to shine at Old Trafford. But if his performances for Everton this season—especially Monday night's dazzling display—are any indication, United might be ruing that decision.

Garner was the heartbeat of Everton's midfield in a wild 3-3 draw against Manchester City at Hill Dickinson Stadium. His assist for Jake O'Brien's goal, a moment of calm precision under pressure, was just the highlight of a masterclass performance. Playing at the base of David Moyes's midfield against one of the Premier League's most technically gifted sides, Garner didn't just hold his own—he dominated.

He completed every single pass in his own half, won all four of his tackle attempts, and created a big chance that kept Everton in the fight. This wasn't a one-off flash of brilliance; it's been the story of his season. Garner hasn't missed a single league game for Everton in 2025-26, boasts an 87% passing accuracy (best in the squad), and leads the team in interceptions (1.6 per game) and tackles (3.2 per game).

That consistency earned him his first senior England cap in March, with Thomas Tuchel calling him a "mini Valverde" for his all-around quality. For Manchester United, the appeal is obvious. Casemiro's contract is winding down, the midfield needs serious reinforcement, and while Elliot Anderson remains a primary target, finding high-quality alternatives is tough. Garner fits the bill perfectly—and at a fraction of the cost of the marquee names being chased elsewhere.

Sometimes, the best solution is the one that got away.