The Tennessee Titans hold a golden ticket with the No. 4 overall pick in the 2026 NFL Draft, and the debate over how to use it is heating up. While the allure of a top running back like Jeremiyah Love is real, the modern NFL calculus often favors a different path. For a team looking to support a young quarterback like Cam Ward, securing a true number-one wide receiver could be the more impactful move.
Enter Ohio State's Carnell Tate, the consensus top receiver in this class. The buzz around Tate is growing louder by the day, with some analysts, including NFL Network's Daniel Jeremiah, suggesting his name could be called as high as second overall. This rising stock makes the Titans' decision at number four even more fascinating.
So, what does Tate bring to the gridiron? On film, he's a technician—a savvy, 6-foot-2 route-runner who creates separation with nuance rather than just raw speed. He boasts strong hands, excels in contested catch situations, and can stretch the field vertically. While his official 4.53-second 40-yard dash time raised some eyebrows, hand-timed results suggested he might be even faster, and his game tape shows a player whose football IQ compensates for any lack of elite deep speed.
The primary critique is his yards-after-catch explosiveness, but it's worth noting Tate was playing opposite a generational talent in Jeremiah Smith at Ohio State. His 875-yard, nine-touchdown 2025 season is impressive within that context, showcasing an ascending 21-year-old talent whose best football is likely ahead of him.
For the Titans, the question isn't just about talent, but positional value. If Tate and a player like Love are graded similarly on their board, the strategic choice to draft the premier wide receiver could accelerate their offensive rebuild. Selecting Tate at four may seem bold, but in today's pass-happy league, securing a cornerstone receiver is a move that pays dividends for years to come.