The 2025 Indianapolis Colts' season was a story of soaring highs and a crushing low. After climbing to the top of the AFC South, their playoff hopes were dashed by a devastating injury to quarterback Daniel Jones. Now, with Jones back in the fold on a new two-year deal, the franchise faces a pivotal question: is their quarterback the true treasure, or do they need to fortify the roster around him to complete the quest?
General Manager Chris Ballard has been far from quiet this offseason, making significant investments to keep the core together. The headline move was securing star wide receiver Alec Pierce with a massive four-year contract, ensuring a premier weapon for Jones. The defense also received a boost with the additions of veteran edge rusher Arden Key and defensive lineman Michael Clemons, bolstering a unit that aims to be more disruptive.
Despite these key signings, the Colts' path to sustained success likely runs through the 2026 NFL Draft. However, they enter with a challenge, holding only three selections in the first four rounds. This scarcity makes every pick crucial, but Ballard's history suggests this could change. He's famously stated, "We like to acquire picks," hinting that the Colts may be active traders to accumulate more capital and address their needs.
So, where might they look? Linebacker is a position to watch. Texas standout Anthony Hill Jr., drawing comparisons to a young Bobby Wagner, is a do-it-all defender who could be a perfect fit in Lou Anarumo's system. While seen as a future Pro Bowler, he may be available when the Colts pick in the second round, offering tremendous value for an inexperienced linebacker corps.
Another key need is adding depth and explosion to the defensive line. Tennessee edge rusher Joshua Josephs presents an intriguing mid-round option. With a long frame and developing pass-rush skills, he has the tools to become a menacing rotational player, providing the spark off the bench that the Colts' front four currently lacks.
Finally, don't rule out the Colts adding another weapon for Daniel Jones. The draft profile of a player like Wisconsin's Skyler Bell—a quick, reliable mid-round receiver—fits the mold of past Colts selections. While securing him might require a strategic move up the board, adding another target could be the final piece to unlock the offense's full potential for the 2026 campaign.