Guardians urged to promote 1.243 OPS catcher despite just trading for Patrick Bailey

2 min read
Guardians urged to promote 1.243 OPS catcher despite just trading for Patrick Bailey

Guardians urged to promote 1.243 OPS catcher despite just trading for Patrick Bailey

This could form a dynamic duo at the catcher position.

Guardians urged to promote 1.243 OPS catcher despite just trading for Patrick Bailey

This could form a dynamic duo at the catcher position.

The Cleveland Guardians find themselves in an intriguing spot this season. At 21-21, they're sitting atop a struggling AL Central division, and with a real chance to capture the crown, they're looking for every edge to boost their offense. That's what made their recent trade for Patrick Bailey—a defensive-minded catcher from the San Francisco Giants—such a fascinating move.

But here's where it gets interesting. Despite bringing in Bailey to bolster the catcher room alongside Bo Naylor, there's a growing call from analysts to promote a red-hot prospect who's absolutely mashing in the minors. Christopher Kline of Fansided.com is urging the Guardians to give a look to Cooper Ingle, a catcher sporting a jaw-dropping 1.243 OPS this season.

"The Guardians clearly value his defense and his game manager IQ behind the plate, but Cleveland always needs more boppers," Kline writes. "Cooper Ingle could be the next man up."

Ingle's numbers are nothing short of spectacular. In 20 games at Triple-A, he's hitting .370 with 20 hits, 17 runs, two doubles, five home runs, and 19 RBIs. He's also drawn 22 walks while striking out just 15 times—a plate discipline that screams big-league readiness.

Of course, calling up a catcher just to have him sit on the bench wouldn't make much sense. The Guardians would need to find a way to get Ingle into the lineup consistently. That could mean giving him time as the designated hitter, where his offensive upside could shine. Some might argue his bat is so good that he should be starting over Bailey anyway.

But here's the beauty of this situation: the Guardians could actually form a dynamic duo behind the plate. Bailey brings elite defense and game-calling, while Ingle provides the power and on-base threat. They could rotate based on matchups, with Ingle also getting DH at-bats when Bailey is behind the dish. It's a win-win that gives Cleveland flexibility and offensive firepower—exactly what a division contender needs.

Like this article?

Order custom jerseys for your team with free design

Back to All News