The early weeks of the fantasy baseball season are a gold rush on the waiver wire. New closers emerge, starting pitchers debut new pitches, and hitters get hot out of nowhere. But to grab those rising stars, you need to make tough cuts. The hardest part of April roster management isn't just finding the adds—it's identifying the drops.
Let's look at some players who are currently over-rostered in Yahoo leagues. This isn't a mandate to cut them immediately, as your specific league format might justify holding. However, if you're looking to stream a hot bat or stash a promising arm, these are the types of players you should consider moving on from to free up that crucial roster spot.
First up, Dennis Santana of the Pirates (81% rostered). While he's undoubtedly Pittsburgh's best reliever, his role has shifted. He's being deployed as a high-leverage fireman, not a traditional closer. This means his save opportunities will be unpredictable. In most leagues, his roster rate should be 15-20% lower.
Next, Carlos Estévez of the Royals (71% rostered). The situation here is clear: he's on the IL, has lost velocity, and has lost his closing job. If you need that IL spot, he's an easy cut. Consider stashing injured starters with higher upside like Merrill Kelly, Shane Bieber, or Joe Musgrove instead, who are all less rostered than Estévez.
Then there's Robert Suarez of the Braves (61% rostered). His past success (76 saves in '24-'25) is keeping him on rosters, but he's no longer the closer in Atlanta. Raisel Iglesias has that job locked down and is pitching well. Suarez is rostered more than most elite setup men and isn't the top candidate to vulture saves. It's time to swap him for an active closer or a setup man behind a shakier ninth-inning option.
Finally, Griffin Jax of the Rays (41% rostered). Tampa Bay's bullpen usage is always creative, and Jax has been used in various high-leverage spots. The problem? None have been the ninth inning. Without a clear path to saves, he's a luxury in most standard leagues when you could be chasing categories.
Making these early, sometimes painful, cuts is key to staying agile. Freeing up roster space allows you to pivot quickly, chase the week's hottest performers, and build a team that can compete all season long. Don't let past performance blind you to current reality—the waiver wire waits for no one.