Six of the past seven editions of the NFL draft have seen at least one Florida Gator taken in the first round after the Minnesota Vikings made defensive lineman Caleb Banks the 18th pick on Thursday night.

Banks is a talented athlete who has been dealing with a broken foot since last summer, limiting him to just three games during the 2025 campaign. However, his previous performances gave everyone a glimpse of his potential when fully healthy, which helped to push him up the draft board.

Gator Wire's Michael Long offered his take on how Banks fits with the Vikings, citing his "ability to fit in both three- and four-man fronts," which represents "a level of versatility rare for his physical profile." He also notes that his "ability to penetrate gaps and handle double teams can be instantly impactful for Brian Flores' defense."

However, some in the national sports media were not feeling the move by Minnesota, criticizing the selection of a player who is still working through his physical recovery and has shown some weaknesses in his overall skillset.

USA TODAY Sports' Michael Middlehurst-Schwartz included Banks in his list of the NFL draft's most head-scratching picks. He voices a significant lack of faith in both the health and talent of the former Gator.

"Equipping Brian Flores with a 6-6, 327-pound missile off the line of scrimmage might seem like a surefire way for Minnesota's defense to up its chaos quotient. Ultimately, the move might end up doing that in the wrong way," he begins.

"When he's healthy and locked in, Banks is easily the most talented and disruptive defensive tackle in this class. He's a load for any offensive tackle to keep at bay, and he's nimble enough to put himself in position to finish off plays in the backfield rather than just throw them off course," he continues.

"Part of the problem: He rarely actually does so, with missed tackles an all-too-common problem. That's just one facet of the inconsistency that has come to define Banks' game. His subpar hand usage and leverage also allow less athletically gifted opponents to neutralize him without much trouble. And with two significant foot injuries sidelining him for much of the last year, his ability to stay on the field will loom large over his pro future."

ESPN's Mel Kiper Jr. mostly concurs with Middlehurst-Schwartz, as the Banks pick was part of his list of questionable picks and reaches from the first round.

"Big-time reach for me. Banks was No. 62 on my board, the biggest stretch of the night. Sure, there's reason to believe this could work out for the Vikings. Banks can stop running backs in their tracks, and he gets enough interior push to be a factor in the pass rush. He moves well for a 6-foot-6, 327-pounder," he says.

"But he has been dealing with a foot injury for a while now, and he just had surgery on it after the combine. A lot of risk here... Not sure I understand this one."

CBS Sports' Josh Edwards did not offer as much in the way of an opinion, but the Banks pick did land lower on his first-round rankings than it did in the draft, coming in at No. 22.

"There are concerns about the struggle of Banks' foot, but not about the player and his capabilities. He is a long interior defender who will collapse the pocket in Brian Flores' defense, but he has to do a better job of finishing," he notes.

Finally, there is The Athletic's Nick Baumgardner and Scott Dochterman, who took on the task of grading all 32 picks in the first round. Their assessment is not nearly as scathing as the first two entries, but his mediocre C-plus grade for the selection certainly leaves plenty to be desired.

"This is bold (if that’s the right word)," they begin.

"When Banks is healthy and engaged with his technique, he’s a serious problem — on talent alone, he’s definitely DT1 in this class. However, he’s not a very consistent player, and despite his athletic potential, he could bust. Banks has had two serious foot injuries in less than a year, and many teams dropped him out of the first round after he broke his foot at the combine," they offer.

"The Vikings could’ve had a perfect fit to fill a need here, in Oregon safety Dillon Thieneman. Instead, they made a serious gamble on a recently injured, albeit very talented, athlete. It’s too big a risk for my taste, though I could easily be proven wrong in a year. We’ll see."

Overall, it appears that the national sports media is feeling pretty bearish about Florida's lone first-round pick. Nonetheless, the Gator Nation will be behind him as he looks to prove the naysayers wrong at the next level.

Follow us @GatorsWire on X, formerly known as Twitter, as well as Bluesky, and like our page on Facebook to follow ongoing coverage of Florida Gators news, notes and opinions.

This article originally appeared on Gators Wire: Reactions to Minnesota's selection of Caleb Banks in 2026 NFL Draft