In a match that had everything—drama, skill, and heartbreak—Everton came agonizingly close to toppling the Premier League champions. After a first half where they were completely outplayed, the Toffees stormed back to take a stunning 3-1 lead against Manchester City. But football can be cruel, and two late goals, including another stoppage-time sucker punch, meant this was a game that slipped through their fingers.
The second half was electric, a rare thrill for the home fans, and the player ratings reflect a mix of heroics and missed opportunities. Here's how each player fared:
Goalkeeper: Beaten three times by world-class finishes, but he did well to punch a corner clear under pressure. A tough night against elite talent.
Defenders: Solid defending all around, with one standout moment—a brilliant header from Garner's corner that showed real poise. The defensive linchpin was as narky as ever, a true leader at the back. Another came close to a red card with a reckless tackle but was otherwise okay. Some important interventions were made, though going forward, he was less effective.
Midfielders: Tremendous work in the absence of Gana Gueye, with one midfielder closer to his best, delivering good set-piece deliveries—one absolutely perfect. Huge energy was on display, with one player all over the pitch, working tirelessly to drive forward and create the third goal, even if his shot was terrible. Another did his best to inject energy and drive, but his one shot was poor, and things didn't quite click.
Forwards: Another exhibition of flattering to deceive—jinking runs that excite the crowd, but achieving nothing in terms of end product. Two glorious chances were spurned, leaving fans frustrated. One forward was a bit exposed by City's high skill level, making him look more clumsy than usual. But redemption came for another, who scored two crucial goals, taking them well and giving City's defenders plenty to think about.
Substitute: A late sub did his best to move things forward when he got the ball, showing intent but unable to change the outcome.
Manager: To surrender a win to yet another last-gasp goal is unforgivable. He got lucky this week with his default Beto-Barry switch but failed to make sure of the game when Everton had a 3-1 lead. The fans will be left wondering what might have been.