Heading into the 2026 NFL season, the Indianapolis Colts find themselves in a frustrating position: near the top of a list no franchise wants to lead. They currently hold the third-longest active playoff drought in the league.
The New York Jets sit in an unenviable first place, having missed the postseason for 15 straight years. The Atlanta Falcons are next, absent for eight seasons, while the Colts and New Orleans Saints are tied, both last making a playoff appearance five years ago. For Indianapolis, that was back in 2020 under the leadership of head coach Frank Reich and GM Chris Ballard.
The big question now is whether this Colts squad can snap that streak. CBS Sports analyst John Breech recently ranked the likelihood of these four drought-ridden teams making the 2026 playoffs, and the outlook for Indy isn't the most optimistic. Breech placed the Jets fourth, with the Colts third, suggesting the Saints and Falcons have a better shot at the postseason this year.
Breech's reasoning points to the fierce competition in the AFC. "The Colts could certainly win nine or 10 games this year, but it took 11 games to make the playoffs in the AFC last season and Indy could have a tough time getting to that number," he wrote.
The team's offseason strategy has centered on continuity, particularly on offense. The front office prioritized re-signing quarterback Daniel Jones, banking on him recapturing the form that made the Colts look like one of the NFL's best teams through the first ten games last season. Securing wide receiver Alec Pierce was another key move to keep that offensive momentum alive.
However, significant questions remain. Jones is returning from a major injury, and the roster still has noticeable gaps heading into the draft. The defense lacks a proven high-impact pass rusher to complement Laiatu Latu, the linebacker corps is inexperienced, and the safety spot next to Cam Bynum is unclear. On offense, identifying a reliable WR3 and bolstering depth along the offensive line are pressing needs.
While the core is intact, the Colts must successfully address these holes if they hope to climb out of the AFC's brutal playoff race and finally end their postseason famine.
