What started as a chance meeting in a hospital hallway during the height of the pandemic has blossomed into a coaching partnership that will take two Indiana high school basketball coaches to Iowa.
In April 2020, Garrett Winegar and J.R. Howell were both navigating the uncertain early days of COVID-19. Their paths had crossed before—Winegar was an assistant at Warren Central when the school defeated Howell's Carmel squad in the 2018 Class 4A state finals. But it was a personal milestone that truly brought them together.
While their wives, Sable Winegar and Kate Howell, were recovering from childbirth just two doors apart at Ascension St. Vincent Hospital in Carmel, the two coaches bumped into each other on the way to the cafeteria. That hallway conversation sparked a friendship—and the arrival of their first-born sons, Jack Howell and Guyton Winegar, sealed the bond.
Fast forward six years, and that bond is taking them to the heartland. Winegar, fresh off a state championship run at Fishers High School, recently accepted a position at Iowa United Prep in Des Moines. He'll coach the "Orange" Team, a squad of freshmen and sophomores, while former Indiana guard Keith Smart leads the "Black" Team of upperclassmen on the Nike EYBL Scholastic circuit.
Once Winegar solidified his role on the Iowa United Prep staff, he didn't hesitate to reach out to his old friend. "I didn't know if we would do it," Winegar admitted. "It's a big move."
After careful consideration, Howell decided the leap was worth taking. He informed his Zionsville team Tuesday morning that he was stepping down after six seasons, posting a 77-62 record. His coaching journey has also included stops at Caston (2013-15) and Western Boone.
"I've been friends with Garrett for a while now, and we've had some other connections that have bonded us since then," Howell said. "This opportunity presented itself, and it was intriguing for me to grow as a coach and a person."
For Howell, the move aligns with a long-standing goal: transitioning into college coaching. This new role could provide the platform he needs to make that jump. In the meantime, two families who met by chance are now taking on a new challenge together, proving that sometimes the best plays are the ones you never see coming.
