The question from a fan cuts to the heart of Celtic's turbulent season: did the brief and chaotic Wilfred Nancy experiment ultimately cost the Bhoys the Scottish Premiership title? While the league trophy could still find its way to Parkhead, the damage from that period is undeniable.

Let's set the scene. Following Brendan Rodgers' departure, interim boss Martin O'Neill had expertly steadied the ship, stringing together five straight league wins and restoring a sense of order. The momentum was with the champions. Then came the appointment of Wilfred Nancy, a bold move to install the former Columbus Crew head coach and his progressive, possession-heavy philosophy.

The gamble backfired spectacularly. Nancy's tenure, the shortest in the club's history, became a case study in disruptive transition. His debut home match set the tone: a 2-1 loss to a Hearts side that had been struggling for form. Missed chances and defensive disarray became hallmarks of his six-game league stint, which yielded four losses and a critical 12 dropped points.

In the high-stakes environment of a title race, that kind of collapse is catastrophic. Had those points remained on Celtic's tally, they would likely be celebrating another championship. Instead, Nancy's attempt to implement a radical culture change overnight acted like a wrecking ball to the team's rhythm and confidence, a period from which the squad has struggled to fully recover.

For a club of Celtic's stature, where consistency is the bedrock of success, this episode serves as a stark reminder. In football, as in performance sportswear, the right fit is everything. A sudden, ill-suited change can unravel even the strongest foundations, leaving a team—and its supporters—to pick up the pieces of a season that promised so much more.