The Tampa Bay Buccaneers' backfield is under the microscope as the 2026 NFL Draft approaches, and one lingering question revolves around Bucky Irving: Can he truly step up as a primary option? Bleacher Report recently raised this very concern, and for good reason.

Irving's 2025 season was a rollercoaster of flashes and frustrations. While he showed undeniable skill in open space, his consistency as a full-time runner left much to be desired. A glance at his game log tells the story—multiple outings where he struggled to crack 3.0 yards per carry, including a 2.6-yard average against both Atlanta and the Jets, and a dismal 2.1 against Miami. Even when given a heavy workload, the efficiency didn't match, like his 26-carry, 85-yard performance against Carolina (a mere 3.3 yards per attempt). To be fair, there were bright spots—4.2 yards per carry against Houston and Philadelphia—but those moments were too few and far between.

Irving has proven he can contribute in the right situations, but the leap to a reliable lead back remains elusive. Durability also plays a role, making it tough to bank on him as an every-down force over a grueling 17-game season.

As the Buccaneers head into 2026 without a clear pecking order in the backfield, the door is wide open for competition. Until someone proves they can handle the load consistently, expect a shared workload—and that's where Irving still has work to do. For fantasy owners and Bucs fans alike, the question isn't just about talent; it's about whether Irving can turn potential into production when it matters most.