Welcome back to another edition of the Avalanche Mailbag, where we dive into the burning questions from Avs Nation. Today, we're tackling two major topics on every fan's mind as the playoffs loom: the future of head coach Jared Bednar and the defensive evolution of superstar Nathan MacKinnon.
First up, a question from Brad J. asks how deep the Avalanche need to go in the postseason for Jared Bednar to secure a contract extension, or if his job is safe even with a first-round exit.
The short answer? It's rarely that simple. While a major meltdown could change the calculus, the prevailing belief is that Bednar is likely to remain behind the bench. Coaching tenures in the NHL aren't always dictated by a simple win-or-go-home playoff result; context is king.
Think back to the 2020 second-round loss to Dallas. That series was defined by a catastrophic run of injuries, losing both goaltenders and seeing captain Gabriel Landeskog play through a gruesome knee injury. In scenarios like that, where circumstances spiral beyond a coach's control, it's hard to pin the loss solely on the man behind the bench.
Contrast that with a situation like Pete DeBoer's exit from Dallas last year. A coach's fate can hinge on how a team loses—or wins. DeBoer's public criticism of his goalie after a series victory ultimately cost him his job, proving it's not just about the round you exit, but the manner in which you do it.
So, for Bednar and the Avs, a first-round loss in a vacuum would likely be unacceptable for a team with Stanley Cup aspirations. But if injuries mount or the series is lost in a hard-fought, seven-game battle against a powerhouse, the narrative shifts. His job security likely hinges less on a specific round and more on the story of the series: Was the team prepared? Did they compete? Or did they simply get outplayed?
For a franchise that's tasted recent glory, expectations are sky-high. But judging a coach requires looking at the full picture, not just the playoff bracket. The coming weeks will write that story.
