Just when it seemed Manchester United had turned a corner, a familiar question has resurfaced: are they truly back? A stunning 2-1 defeat to Leeds United at Old Trafford has poured cold water on any burgeoning optimism, leaving Michael Carrick and his squad with serious questions to answer as the Premier League season reaches its climax.

The loss, a significant blow in the race for European qualification, exposed familiar frailties. Despite controlling possession for large periods, United lacked the cutting edge and defensive solidity needed to see off a spirited Leeds side. This result is a stark reminder that consistency, not just flashes of brilliance, defines a top team.

For Leeds, it was a classic smash-and-grab away performance, executed with grit and lethal efficiency on the counter-attack. Their victory at the Theatre of Dreams underscores the unpredictable nature of the Premier League, where any team can triumph on their day if the fundamentals are right.

As the final whistle blew, the focus shifted squarely to Carrick's men. With crucial fixtures ahead, this setback forces a sobering evaluation. How much better can this United side get in the final stretch? The performance against Leeds suggests there is still significant work to do to transform promise into a sustained, winning formula.