AEW stars who left for WWE: Ranking the most —and least — successful jumps, from Danhausen to Cody Rhodes

3 min read
AEW stars who left for WWE: Ranking the most —and least — successful jumps, from Danhausen to Cody Rhodes

AEW stars who left for WWE: Ranking the most —and least — successful jumps, from Danhausen to Cody Rhodes

Is the grass always greener on the other side? Not so when it comes to pro-wrestling, where the past few weeks have provided a pointed reminder about the uneven fates of those who switch from AEW to WWE.

AEW stars who left for WWE: Ranking the most —and least — successful jumps, from Danhausen to Cody Rhodes

Is the grass always greener on the other side? Not so when it comes to pro-wrestling, where the past few weeks have provided a pointed reminder about the uneven fates of those who switch from AEW to WWE.

In the world of professional wrestling, the grass isn't always greener—but sometimes, it's a whole different shade. The past few weeks have reminded fans just how unpredictable the jump from AEW to WWE can be, with some stars skyrocketing to fame while others fade into the shadows. Let's break down the most—and least—successful transitions, from the hilarious Danhausen to the legendary Cody Rhodes.

Take Danhausen, for instance. A comedy mid-carder who barely made a blip on AEW's radar, he was practically invisible during his time with Tony Khan's promotion. But after a surprise move to WWE, the face-painted entertainer has become a breakout star on "SmackDown," even landing among the top three merchandise sellers at this year's WrestleMania. It's a classic underdog story, but we're only a few months into his WWE run, so the jury's still out—novelty acts can fade as quickly as they rise.

Then there's Aleister Black, the former AEW Trios Champion who made the switch back to WWE last year. Despite hype video packages and a promising feud with Randy Orton, the martial artist was unceremoniously released last week, alongside his wife, Zelina Vega. A stark reminder that even the most hyped returns can fall flat.

Royce Keys is another wildcard. He's getting a massive television push, signaling that WWE sees huge potential in him. But with no concrete plans yet revealed, it's too early to call him a success or failure. Similarly, Paige's shock return at WrestleMania 42 was a highlight, but she's still got plenty to prove—especially after a lukewarm AEW run. She's already wearing tag-team gold, but the real test lies ahead.

Andrade's back-and-forth journey between the two companies has been a rollercoaster, but his recent WWE run shows flashes of brilliance. Meanwhile, Cody Rhodes stands as the ultimate success story—leaving AEW to become one of WWE's biggest stars, main-eventing WrestleMania and cementing his legacy. For every Danhausen riding high, there's an Aleister Black left wondering what went wrong. In the end, it's all about timing, momentum, and the unpredictable nature of pro wrestling.

Like this article?

Order custom jerseys for your team with free design

Back to All News