The New York Jets have their starting quarterback for the 2026 season locked in—Geno Smith is QB1. But if last season taught us anything, it's that a starter isn't guaranteed to finish the year under center. At 35 years old and coming off a league-leading 17 interceptions, Smith's hold on the job is far from ironclad. After all, the Jets tied for the NFL's worst record at 3-14 in 2025, so the margin for error is razor-thin.
Currently, the depth chart behind Smith includes fourth-round rookie Cade Klubnik out of Clemson, who's viewed as a developmental project and potential long-term answer. Then there's Brady Cook, an undrafted free agent from 2025, and Bailey Zappe, a 27-year-old former fourth-round pick. But with training camp approaching, it's no sure thing that Cook or Zappe will make the final roster. The Jets recently extended a contract offer to veteran Russell Wilson, signaling they're still hunting for reliable depth. While Wilson mulls that offer—along with other opportunities—New York may need to pivot. Here are five quarterback options the Jets should consider to back up—or push—Geno Smith in 2026.
1. Russell Wilson
The most obvious connection: Wilson has already visited the Jets and likely still has a place in New York after playing for the Giants last season. Rumors have long swirled that he and his wife Ciara prefer the New York area. If Wilson wants to keep playing, the contract details shouldn't be a dealbreaker. Plus, there's a strong chance he'd see the field—the Jets aren't exactly expected to be contenders. The real question is whether New York wants someone with more long-term upside.
2. Jimmy Garoppolo
Garoppolo, who turns 35 in November, has spent the last two seasons as Matthew Stafford's backup and is reportedly considering retirement. But if he's still looking to cash a few checks without taking on too much risk, why not sign with the Jets? He'd bring veteran poise and a quick release to a room that could use a steady hand. Plus, the New York market offers plenty of visibility—even for a backup.
3. Carson Wentz
Once an MVP candidate, Wentz has bounced around the league as a backup in recent years. At 33, he still has the arm talent and mobility to step in if Smith struggles or gets injured. The Jets could offer him a chance to rebuild his value—and potentially compete for the starting job if Smith falters early.
4. Jameis Winston
Winston is a high-risk, high-reward option who knows how to move the ball—and how to turn it over. He'd bring energy and experience to the quarterback room, and his aggressive style could push Smith in practice. If the Jets want a backup who can rally the team and isn't afraid to throw deep, Winston fits the bill.
5. Trey Lance
The 49ers' former No. 3 overall pick is still just 26 years old and has the athleticism to thrive in a modern offense. Lance has bounced around since leaving San Francisco, but the raw talent is undeniable. For a team like the Jets that isn't expected to contend, Lance offers intriguing upside as a developmental project who could eventually challenge for the starting job.
Whether the Jets land Wilson or pivot to another veteran, adding a proven backup is essential for a team that can't afford another lost season. With Geno Smith's inconsistency and the youth behind him, New York's quarterback room needs a safety net—and potentially a spark.