The first round of the 2026 NFL Draft delivered its share of surprises Thursday night in Pittsburgh. Some players flew off the board earlier than expected. Others waited by the phone all night and never got the call. This happens every year.
This list focuses on the latter group. Five prospects who entered draft week with legitimate first-round grades, backed by real production and in some cases years of tape that made the argument plain as day. Medical red flags, measurement concerns, off-field questions, and the sheer volume of talent at certain positions all played a role in keeping them off the board.
Each of these players will be selected on Friday in Rounds 2 or 3. Each of them will immediately become one of the better values in this entire draft class for the team that takes them.
MORE: Viral Makai Lemon video unveils chaotic Steelers-Eagles NFL Draft drama
6’1″, 230 lbs | 2025 stats: 88 tackles, 8 TFL, 3.5 sacks
CJ Allen did not slip out of the first round because of anything he did wrong on a football field. He slipped because he skipped the combine drills while rehabbing an undisclosed injury, and in a draft process where measurables carry enormous weight, that absence created doubt where there should be none.
The tape is clean across three seasons at Georgia: 88 tackles, 8 tackles for loss and 0 missed tackles per PFF in 2025. A team captain and green dot linebacker trusted to run one of the most disciplined defenses in college football. His instincts against the run are genuinely elite, and his zone coverage is reliable enough to stay on the field on third down.
The one legitimate knock is man coverage against athletic tight ends and running backs, where his hip stiffness shows up. That is a real limitation worth monitoring. But it is one correctable area in a profile that is otherwise ready for Sunday. The team that gets Allen early in Day 2 is getting a first-round player at a significant discount.
6’0”, 188 lbs | 2024 stats: 44 tackles, 4 INTs, 9 PBUs (missed all of 2025)
Jermod McCoy entered the pre-draft process as arguably the most talented cornerback in this class. He left Thursday night still on the board, and the reason has nothing to do with football.
McCoy tore his ACL in January 2025 during an offseason training session. He never played a snap for Tennessee last season. His pro day in March appeared to quiet the concerns. He ran a 4.37 forty, posted a 38-inch vertical and worked through drills without any visible limitation. Then, the NFL Network’s Tom Pelissero reported that teams had red-flagged a bone plug used to repair a cartilage defect in his knee during medical rechecks. That was the moment the first round door closed.
In 2024, there was little doubt given his four interceptions, nine pass breakups and top grades among all cornerbacks by PFF. Without the injury, McCoy was a certain top 15 pick. The team willing to trust its medical staff and bet on a full recovery is getting a potential lockdown corner at a fraction of that price.
6’4″, 212 lbs | 2025 stats: 62 receptions, 881 yards, 11 TDs
Denzel Boston did not fall out of the first round because of anything that showed up on film. He fell because the draft went wide receiver heavy early, and the position ran dry before teams got back around to him.
Five receivers went in the first round. Boston was not among them despite posting back-to-back seasons of 60-plus catches and double-digit touchdowns for Washington. His career contested catch rate is among the best in this class. He caught 20 touchdowns over his final two college seasons. Multiple evaluators have him ranked as the top available receiver heading into Day 2.
The legitimate knock on Boston is speed and separation. He is not going to consistently beat press coverage with athleticism alone and will need schemed releases at the next level. His forty time did not help his cause in that regard.
What he does bring is the kind of physicality, hands and red zone dominance that translates immediately. The 49ers hold the first pick of Day 2 and have a receiver need. Boston slipping to them would qualify as one of the better value picks of this entire draft.
6’2″, 253 lbs | 2025 stats: 31 tackles, 14 TFL, 11.5 sacks, 41 pressures
Cashius Howell led the SEC in sacks in 2025. He was a unanimous All-American. He posted a 19.9 percent pass rush win rate in each of his final two college seasons against top competition. Then he walked into the combine measurement room, and his arms came in at 30 1/4 inches, the shortest recorded for a pure edge rusher since 1999, and the first round conversation was effectively over.
His response when asked about the criticism? “I ball out.” He is not wrong. The production across five college seasons at two programs has been remarkably consistent. He won at Bowling Green, won playing behind two eventual first-rounders at Texas A&M, and then won as the featured pass rusher in the SEC. That is not a fluke resume.