The sudden departure of Marvin Bartley from Livingston has left fans reeling, with many describing the decision as "unbelievable" and a move that leaves a "sour taste" as the club prepares for next season. Bartley stepped down as manager, paving the way for Scott Arfield to take over as interim boss—a change that has sparked mixed emotions among supporters.

Fan Derek acknowledges Bartley's solid performance, noting he "did a decent job and can leave with his head held high." However, Derek voices a lingering concern: "It's a difficult situation as I still feel David Martindale is pulling the strings somewhere, and that hasn't changed." He argues that Martindale's influence must end for the club to "move forward," while expressing optimism that Arfield—a "great lad"—will impress the board and finish the season strong.

Garry captures the collective frustration, saying, "Just as fans were starting to look towards next season with a bit of positivity... Livi happens! From the outside, this is not a good look." This sentiment echoes throughout the fanbase, as the timing of Bartley's exit feels particularly jarring.

Malky is more direct, calling the situation "unbelievable." He praises Bartley for steadying the ship, uniting the squad, and giving fans "a glimmer of hope for next season," only to feel betrayed by behind-the-scenes forces. Jo adds a practical take: "That's terrible from Livingston, feel sorry for Bartley. However, like all business nowadays, get it in a contract or writing, not verbally, as it stands for nothing." Jo suspects the club never intended to keep Bartley for a promotion push, hence the "reapply" directive.

Craig shares a similar disappointment, believing Bartley was "the right man going forward." He criticizes the shifting goalposts, noting the departure comes at a critical time when players are out of contract. "It leaves a sour taste in the mouth," Craig says, questioning the choice of Arfield over Andrew Shinnie and hoping Calvin Ford's influence doesn't "come back to haunt us."

As Livingston navigates this turbulent transition, the fans' message is clear: stability and trust are needed to build on any momentum for the seasons ahead.